Subscribe to RSS Feed Log in

A Battlefield Tourist

Thursday
4 December 2008

US Pulls Out of Wanat; Base in Nuristan Not First to be Nearly Overrun

Leaving behind a handful of weapons for the Afghan security forces, paratroopers with Chosen Company, 2/503 have withdrawn from the area of Want, Nuristan Province, as they prepare to leave the country for a planned rotation.

As the Americans pulled out, Afghan forces withdrew to Kunar Province allowing militant fighters to move back into a town that will go down in history as one of the deadliest for US troops in this central Asian country.

Military officials say the move does not mean security will be abandoned in Wanat, noting that Afghan forces will continue to operate in the region as will coalition air missions.  An Afghan operation in the area July 15 killed seven militants.

Chosen Nearly Overrun in August

The attack in Wanat (Want) has taken the American public by surprise, mostly because of the casualties involved.  However, direct attacks on small coalition outposts do occasionally occur in Afghanistan, but earn little true success.  For Chosen Company, 2/503, the attack in Want is eerily similar to an attack one of the unit’s platoons faced in 2007.

On August 22, 25 members of Chosen Company, 2/503 were manning an isolated outpost near Aranus, Waygol district, Nuristan when a large force of Taliban attacked from multiple sides.  As the attack began, Afghan security contractors abandoned their posts which allowed about 20 militants to breach the outpost walls.  Over the next three hours, the paratroopers fought for their lives using small arms, claymore mines and close air support from A-10s buzzing overhead.  In the end, 11 of 25 soldiers were wounded; none had been killed.

What Next For Nuristan?

In July, Nuristan has been the focus of a major assault by confederated militant forces, many of whom have recently crossed the Pakistani/Afghan border near Chitral.  No updates are coming out of that region, called Bargi Matal, which lies north of Waygol.  There, civilians and police forces have been battling up to 500 militants in that district for the past week.

With US forces pulling out of the Wanat region, and having already closed a base near Aranus, it looks as though the soldiers replacing 2/503 (Third Brigade, First Infantry Division) have their work cut out for them.  With winter making ground transportation in the area almost impossible, there’s a question whether the new units rotating into the area will be able to re-establish a reasonable presence in eastern and central Nuristan before the weather turns bad.

Perhaps with the the extension of the 24th Marine Expeditionary Unit, we’ll soon see the arrival of Marines in an offensive role in Nuristan, with Army units stabilizing the area and preventing the militants from establishing a winter home within the province’s valleys?

Regardless, whether this year or next year, I can see no way the US military will just concede half of Nuristan to the militants, particularly a village that is covered withso much American blood.  The fighting here has really just begun.

5 Responses for "US Pulls Out of Wanat; Base in Nuristan Not First to be Nearly Overrun"

  1. David M

    July 17th, 2008 at 3:29 pm

    1

    The Thunder Run has linked to this post in the blog post From the Front: 07/17/2008 News and Personal dispatches from the front and the home front.

  2. tankerbablelc

    July 18th, 2008 at 6:32 am

    2

    It is so refreshing to know that someone understands the war climate and operations over there. This is the FIRST article I’ve read that gives the details about areas in the Triangle of Death/Vally of Death. I personally know many of the men who were wounded at the Battle at the Ranch House in Aranas back in August 2007.

    The USA isn’t abandoning the firebase near Wanat this week. They made the right decision to NOT put the lives of more of the Sky Soldiers (173rd ABCT) on the line by sending more in now. That area, just as the Ranch House will NEVER be abandoned and the ground consecrated with the blood of our Fallen Heroes will not be forgotten or given up.

  3. gail y

    July 18th, 2008 at 7:39 am

    3

    Who will hold Garmser? Are the British ready to hold the whole area? When does winter really start in Nuristan and Helmand? I really appreciate your articles. I think you are very wise.

  4. David

    July 18th, 2008 at 10:12 am

    4

    Gail -

    Helmand’s winter is not of any real consideration unless you’re in the higher elevations. In Nuristan, things start getting nasty in October.

    As for who will hold Garmser: The British have added some reinforcements to the area and the coalition is working to get an ANA kandak in the area. There are also possibilities with an airborne battalion that is handing over their AO surrounding Kabul. However, this is all pure speculation that is almost unfair to attempt to predict. Earlier this month I posted an article called, “Filling the Void”. It details my armchair general thoughts on this situation.

  5. gail y

    July 18th, 2008 at 10:36 am

    5

    David, thank you so much! I really appreciate your perspective. I’ll go read “filling the void” right now. My son is with 1/6 infantry in Garmser so I am particularly interested in your perspective.


RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a reply