Subscribe to RSS Feed Log in

A Battlefield Tourist

Friday
10 February 2012

Early Bird Gets the Worm

A Marine from India C., 3/8 stands guard over men from a suspected Taliban village in Bakwa district, Farah Province.

A Marine from India C., 3/8 stands guard over men from a suspected Taliban village in Bakwa district, Farah Province.

Feb 9, 2009

After getting a few hours to adjust the day before, I was awaken at 0330 for an operation that was the culmination of nearly two months of intelligence gathering regarding a particular village, the Marines believed, housed an IED cell.  Time and time again the target of this operation’s name has surfaced and now was the time to act.  After all, the Marines here have faced more than 40 IED attacks since arriving in November, which have killed and injured a handful of the young Americans.

Cordon and Search

The operation kicked off even before I was out of bed with various elements establishing a cordon around the target village and two other nearby compounds.   The goal for this is to use the night as cover and to prevent anyone from coming or going as the remainder of the force moved into position.

With the sun rising, the Marines began establishing a processing station that comprised of a a small detention area encircled with concertina wire and a place where all the fighting aged males (usually 16 years +) would be processed by getting names, ages, fingerprints and iris scans.  The goal of this is to create a data base of the potential enemy fighters for future use in the war against the terrorists (yes, fingerprints can be lifted from unexploded IEDs).

Once the cordon was established, the station set and the rising of the sun, the Marines prepared to approach the village.  “Dave, you wait here until we make the initial approach…”, said India Company commander, Captain Michael Hoffman of Naperville, Illinois.  Not being one to watch from the rear, with a smile I gave Captain Hoffman one last chance to reconsider.  “Ok… but if you get shot…”, he said.  “Don’t worry, Captain, I’ll be fine.” 

With two attack choppers and a B-1 Bomber circling overhead, we approached the village to a distance of about 50m away before an Afghan interpreter called for the elders to come out. 

Within a few minutes, an old man dressed in white (typical elder garb) slowly made his way toward our position to see what it was the Marines wanted.   The Marines were looking for specific people, including one who came out early on during the initial assessment, which involved a knee-to-knee sit dow with Captain Hoffman who explained why he was there and how the rest of the day would go.  Once the initial interviews were over, the Marines sent most of the men to the processing station, keeping one elder on hand to take them through the village. 

Team Lioness

Of major concern for Hoffman, at this time, was the women and children of village (due to the cultural sensitivities involved in this part of the world).  That problem was considered well in advance and is why a handful of female Marines and an interpreter were brought in specifically for this mission; a team called Team Lioness. 

As far as Hoffman knew, this idea was first tried in Iraq and now, for the first time employed in Afghanistan.  However a precursor to this idea was employed by Battalion Landing Team (BLT)1/6 back in 2004 in Oruzgan Province. 

At that time, a team called “Charlie’s Angels” (for Charlie Company) were employed to do the exact same thing; work with the women of the village so not to incite cultural issues and to also exploit information from part of a population that often goes untapped during such missions.  Their job was to simply stay with the women, who were confined to the main elder’s compound, interacting with them and the children while the men of the village were rounded up and sent to the processing area. 

Once that was done, the Marines, using the elder as a guide, searched specific homes and all the the villages stores.  There was no door kicking and very few locks that had to be cut as the Marines gave the elder a chance to fetch keys in an effort to minimize damage.

Hoffman is clearly a man who trying hard to work within guidelines that, while asserting authority, goes above and beyond what one would expect in this environment to accommodate the civilians he is charged with protecting.  His approach is firm, yet sensitive, and vital to the success of counterinsurgency in his opinion.  His goal is to work with the population to find the Taliban and weapons caches and not to create friction that would go against his approach that could further alienate the population from his Marines.

The End Result

The biggest problem of the day actually fell on technology.  The system the Marines use to record the vital information created a monster headache for everyone as it took hours to process just 16 males (all adults and one boy approximately 13 years in age).  Some men took more than an hour to process; others needed to be processed several times because the equipment would not cooperate. 

The day was long and hot, as the Afghans sat and waited for the procedure to finish.  The Marines provided blankets and water to help the men sit through the day, who suffered nothing more than from boredom.

In the end, two men were detained for further questioning, including the 80-something year old man who is thought to be provoking the attacks in this area.  That decision became easier as Marines found more than 120 pounds of high explosives and a couple of artillery/rocket rounds in a centuries old tunnel that was probably used to help irrigate the surrounding farmland at one time.  I’m sure another considering factor involved the elder’s attitude toward the Marines and the bombs that were aimed at them; many within sight of the village.  During the initial interview when Captain Hoffman was explaining the issues the Marines faced, the elder adamantly told Hoffman, “That’s your problem.” 

“My problem?”, Hoffman replied.  “This is your country!”

Share/Save/Bookmark

5 Responses for "Early Bird Gets the Worm"

  1. Bev Henderson

    February 11th, 2009 at 9:41 am

    1

    Dear Dave, I have been following your articles since finding it on the marine parent website. Thank you for putting your life at risk to tell the stories for our marines. My son LCpl James Phillips is there with India Co.He is a wonderful son and a true marine.And although he is missed terribly back home, he is where he wants to be.
    Please remind our marines how proud we are of them and their brave hearts. Looking forward to reading your stories and God Bless you and our Marines.
    Proud Mom of LCpl Phillips

  2. David M

    February 11th, 2009 at 3:17 pm

    2

    The Thunder Run has linked to this post in the blog post From the Front: 02/11/2009 News and Personal dispatches from the front and the home front.

  3. Charlotte Barker

    February 12th, 2009 at 12:48 pm

    3

    Dave, I am so sorry but I was confused about the article that mentioned my son. Another reporter had written it. I have just found your site and I am avidly reading. If you see him, my son is 1st Lt Bailey the exec officer with 3/8 India Co. I am so thankful for what the Marines are doing and I appreciated how you described Captain Hoffman. I am praying for all of their safe returns to their families. Thank you for being there and stay safe.

  4. Rastus Riley

    February 14th, 2009 at 2:58 pm

    4

    In reading your piece, I’m appalled. Yes, it’s a dangerous place. Yes, there are bad people there. But when I think of us misguidedly enforcing our ‘value’ system on a culture that finds our way of life reprehensible, your paternal, condescending reporting on what the villagers have to go through leaves me chilled.

    Let me tell you, if I had foreign troops scanning the iris of my 13yr old child, I’d get pissed. If I had foreign troops messing up my crops, I’d do everything I could to resist them. If I had to oversee the breaking of locks on my neighbors doors? How unbelievably degrading.

    “Suffering from no more than boredom?” You call that reporting? How about telling everyone about the suffering and indignity of submitting to a foreign will? No wonder they hate us.

    The area has remained ungoverned for centuries. Afghanistan has beaten every army in the world since the Mongols. How unfortunate it is that our boys are over there, essentially cannon-fodder, until we realize as a nation we can’t always succeed in forcing our culture upon a people that choose to remain steadfast in their own belief system.

    How many of our guys have to die before we see that? Writing about the justifications with emotional triggers doesn’t convince me for a second that we belong there…boredom indeed.

    Once again, ask yourself…if foreign troops were in your backyard, wouldn’t you do everything in your power to boot them out? I think you would.

    ‘Nough said.

    -Rastus
    (proud vet who finally sees the real picture after thinking on what he did over there)

  5. David Tate

    February 15th, 2009 at 12:20 am

    5

    Rastus – You make valid points to an extent. Sure, I can assume there is some amount of humiliation involved, but let’s look at what you write.

    1. “Enforcing our value system…” – This idea is utter nonsense. The ISAF troops I have worked with do not do this. In fact, they go out of their way to do the opposite. You should read the story entitled, “A Walk in the Desert”.
    2. “Breaking of locks on my neighbors door…” – Only one lock needed to be cut, and that was on a storefront when the owner’s keys could not be found. In fact, this raid was house specific, which is the first time, in my experience, it has been done like that.
    3. “Suffering and indignity of submitting to foreign will.” – I will give you a little here. However, understand that the troops acting under what’s called, “Karzai’s 12″. President Karzai has issued 12 standing rules that ISAF troops must follow. These rules are established by the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan and are criteria that Capt. Hoffman follows.
    4. “The area has remained ungoverned for centuries.” – This is true. It is also the primary reason ISAF is in Afghanistan. The lawless nature of this area is what directly led to the attacks on America. It is also the reason why the vast majority of people who want to live here in peace, cannot. They cannot get their goods to market, they are brutalized by islamists and they constantly live in fear. The sole US objective in this area is to provide security and open a road that will help the majority of people live better lives. The villages of this area are not randomly targeted for these types of raids, rather 45 days of intelligence gathering and an unknown number of captured militants all pointed back to this village. Hence the reason this village was targeted for a cordon and search and processing.

    “Nough said.

    -DT


RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a reply